Round 9/History: Difference between revisions

Line 121:

==== The Sequential Proposal Scare ====

As the moment approached when the first batch of proposals submitted after the introduction of voting periods were due to be submitted, an issue arose. Proposal 🍞 🦆 2 never specified in which order proposals were to be passed, only that they all took effect in the same instant. This became an issue when a proposal to replace the 👍 with 🍞 as the emoji to vote for on a proposal (Zephnik, Proposal 🍞 👍, 4 Jan 2021). Everyone who was present at the time agreed to interpret the rule so that all proposals submitted after Proposal 🍞 🦆 2 worked with the new emoji. This interpretation was codified in Proposal 1️ 2 👭 (Klink, 7 Jan 2021) ~~for all future vote resolutions~~.

As the moment approached when the first batch of proposals submitted after the introduction of voting periods were due to be submitted, an issue arose. Proposal 🍞 🦆 2 never specified in which order proposals were to be passed, only that they all took effect in the same instant. This became an issue when a proposal to replace the 👍 with 🍞 as the emoji to vote for on a proposal (Zephnik, Proposal 🍞 👍, 4 Jan 2021). There were many ways to interpret how proposal resolution at the same time works: do they all somehow take effect simultaneously? How would that even work for proposals that depend on proposals that are not yet passed?

Everyone who was present at the time agreed to interpret the rule so that all proposals submitted after Proposal 🍞 🦆 2 worked with the new emoji<ref>https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/796802764759892048</ref>. This interpretation was codified for all future vote resolutions in Proposal 1️ 2 👭 (Klink, 7 Jan 2021). Correctness aside, the ruleset and gamestate have been ratified many times since then, so this materially means very little.

{{Proposal Box

|name=1️ 2 👭

|text=

Amend role "Proposals" by:

1. Replacing the following:

:If that message is deleted or modified during its voting period, the proposal is retracted.

With:

:If that message is deleted or modified before or during its voting period, the proposal is retracted.

Appending the following:

:If more than one proposal takes effect, they take effect in the order in which they were proposed.

}}

=== References ===

@@ Line 121: / Line 121: @@
 ==== The Sequential Proposal Scare ====
-As the moment approached when the first batch of proposals submitted after the introduction of voting periods were due to be submitted, an issue arose. Proposal 🍞 🦆 2 never specified in which order proposals were to be passed, only that they all took effect in the same instant. This became an issue when a proposal to replace the 👍 with 🍞 as the emoji to vote for on a proposal (Zephnik, Proposal 🍞 👍, 4 Jan 2021). Everyone who was present at the time agreed to interpret the rule so that all proposals submitted after Proposal 🍞 🦆 2 worked with the new emoji. This interpretation was codified in Proposal 1️ 2 👭 (Klink, 7 Jan 2021) for all future vote resolutions.
+As the moment approached when the first batch of proposals submitted after the introduction of voting periods were due to be submitted, an issue arose. Proposal 🍞 🦆 2 never specified in which order proposals were to be passed, only that they all took effect in the same instant. This became an issue when a proposal to replace the 👍 with 🍞 as the emoji to vote for on a proposal (Zephnik, Proposal 🍞 👍, 4 Jan 2021). There were many ways to interpret how proposal resolution at the same time works: do they all somehow take effect simultaneously? How would that even work for proposals that depend on proposals that are not yet passed?
+Everyone who was present at the time agreed to interpret the rule so that all proposals submitted after Proposal 🍞 🦆 2 worked with the new emoji<ref>https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/796802764759892048</ref>. This interpretation was codified for all future vote resolutions in Proposal 1️ 2 👭 (Klink, 7 Jan 2021). Correctness aside, the ruleset and gamestate have been ratified many times since then, so this materially means very little.
+{{Proposal Box
+|name=1️ 2 👭
+|text=
+Amend role "Proposals"  by:
+. Replacing the following:
+:If that message is deleted or modified during its voting period, the proposal is retracted.
+With:
+:If that message is deleted or modified before or during its voting period, the proposal is retracted.
+Appending the following:
+:If more than one proposal takes effect, they take effect in the order in which they were proposed.
+}}
 === References ===
 <references />