Cycle 15/Ruleset Draft: Difference between revisions

From Infinite Nomic Wiki
Trungle (talk | contribs)
→‎Winning: clarify crystals
Trungle (talk | contribs)
Promote each rule by one heading level to increase readability
Line 5: Line 5:
is the board specified correctly?
is the board specified correctly?


== Nomic Rules ==
= Nomic Rules =


=== Time ===
== Time ==


==== General ====
=== General ===
All times mentioned in this ruleset are in UTC. Days start at 00:00 UTC. Weeks start on Monday 00:00 UTC.
All times mentioned in this ruleset are in UTC. Days start at 00:00 UTC. Weeks start on Monday 00:00 UTC.


==== Phases ====
=== Phases ===
Each week is divided into two phases:
Each week is divided into two phases:


Line 19: Line 19:
Phase II: Friday, Saturday, and Sunday
Phase II: Friday, Saturday, and Sunday


=== Rules ===
== Rules ==


A rule is a body of text which governs the state of the game. Rules that are in effect apply continuously. When a player joins the game, they agree to abide by the rules in effect.
A rule is a body of text which governs the state of the game. Rules that are in effect apply continuously. When a player joins the game, they agree to abide by the rules in effect.
Line 27: Line 27:
A rule that is not a subrule is a top-level rule.  
A rule that is not a subrule is a top-level rule.  


=== Players ===
== Players ==
Any person may become a player by posting a message setting forth their intent to do so in the channel ⁠#game-actions, provided they have not been a player at any point in the past seven days. A player may cease being a player by sending a message that sets forth their intent to do so in #⁠game-actions.
Any person may become a player by posting a message setting forth their intent to do so in the channel ⁠#game-actions, provided they have not been a player at any point in the past seven days. A player may cease being a player by sending a message that sets forth their intent to do so in #⁠game-actions.


A player is "reputable" if they have continuously been a player for the previous seven days or if they have continuously been a player from a time that was within 3 days of the round starting.
A player is "reputable" if they have continuously been a player for the previous seven days or if they have continuously been a player from a time that was within 3 days of the round starting.


=== Proposals ===
== Proposals ==
Proposals are made by sending a message in the channel #proposals.
Proposals are made by sending a message in the channel #proposals.


Line 41: Line 41:
The class of a proposal must be one of the classes listed below. When a proposal is submitted, the submitter may specify its class. if no class is specified, the proposal class defaults to Standard.
The class of a proposal must be one of the classes listed below. When a proposal is submitted, the submitter may specify its class. if no class is specified, the proposal class defaults to Standard.


==== Urgent Class Proposal ====
=== Urgent Class Proposal ===
The voting period of an urgent proposal begins at the time it is submitted and ends two days (48 hours) after. An urgent proposal is popular if it has no more than two votes against it.
The voting period of an urgent proposal begins at the time it is submitted and ends two days (48 hours) after. An urgent proposal is popular if it has no more than two votes against it.


Rules to the contrary notwithstanding, only a reputable player can submit an urgent proposal. Urgent proposals should only be used to correct the game to its intended state and to maintain playability.
Rules to the contrary notwithstanding, only a reputable player can submit an urgent proposal. Urgent proposals should only be used to correct the game to its intended state and to maintain playability.


==== Standard Class Proposal ====
=== Standard Class Proposal ===
The voting period for a standard proposal is the phase that started after the proposal was submitted. A standard proposal is popular if it has more votes in favor than votes against.
The voting period for a standard proposal is the phase that started after the proposal was submitted. A standard proposal is popular if it has more votes in favor than votes against.


=== Judges ===
== Judges ==
There shall be a sole Judge, responsible for resolving rules disputes. An incumbent Judge can be removed with the assent of two players, but they should not be removed except for abuse of office. A person can cease being the Judge by publicly stating so.
There shall be a sole Judge, responsible for resolving rules disputes. An incumbent Judge can be removed with the assent of two players, but they should not be removed except for abuse of office. A person can cease being the Judge by publicly stating so.


Line 64: Line 64:
Any reputable player may become a candidate for the Judge by sending a message in the channel #judge-elections. If there are any Judge candidacies put forward during a week, the player whose message is both popular and has the most 👍 reactions from players becomes the Judge once that week ends. A Judge Candidacy message is popular if it has more 👍 than 👎 reactions from players on its initiating message. Ties are broken in favor of the player with the earliest text message during that week.
Any reputable player may become a candidate for the Judge by sending a message in the channel #judge-elections. If there are any Judge candidacies put forward during a week, the player whose message is both popular and has the most 👍 reactions from players becomes the Judge once that week ends. A Judge Candidacy message is popular if it has more 👍 than 👎 reactions from players on its initiating message. Ties are broken in favor of the player with the earliest text message during that week.


=== Items ===
== Items ==
Items are entities defined as such by the rules. Items can be owned by players. When an item's owner cannot reasonably be determined using publicly available information, or if it would be owned by a non-player, it is instead destroyed.
Items are entities defined as such by the rules. Items can be owned by players. When an item's owner cannot reasonably be determined using publicly available information, or if it would be owned by a non-player, it is instead destroyed.


Line 73: Line 73:
Reputable players can trade items with other reputable players.
Reputable players can trade items with other reputable players.


==== Trading ====
=== Trading ===
A trade is an exchange or transfer of items between two entities, with each entity giving a specified finite set of items to the other.
A trade is an exchange or transfer of items between two entities, with each entity giving a specified finite set of items to the other.


When otherwise authorized, a trade between two players takes place when both players explicitly consent to the trade in #trades within 7 days of each other.
When otherwise authorized, a trade between two players takes place when both players explicitly consent to the trade in #trades within 7 days of each other.


=== Actions ===
== Actions ==
When defining a game action that can be performed by sending a message, the rules should specify a channel where the game action can be taken. If the rules enable performing an action by sending a message without providing for a specific channel, the action can be taken by sending a message in #game-actions. Similarly, if the rules provide that a game action can be taken without making any provision for any method to take that action, the action can be taken by sending a message in #game-actions.
When defining a game action that can be performed by sending a message, the rules should specify a channel where the game action can be taken. If the rules enable performing an action by sending a message without providing for a specific channel, the action can be taken by sending a message in #game-actions. Similarly, if the rules provide that a game action can be taken without making any provision for any method to take that action, the action can be taken by sending a message in #game-actions.


Line 85: Line 85:
Whenever a player performs an action that would modify the information that the players generally agree should be tracked, that player should make a reasonable effort to track the outcome of the action in the generally-agreed-upon applicable location.
Whenever a player performs an action that would modify the information that the players generally agree should be tracked, that player should make a reasonable effort to track the outcome of the action in the generally-agreed-upon applicable location.


==== Random Choices ====
=== Random Choices ===
A person shall not deliberately select random values for a rules-defined action without intending to use those values to the best of their ability to resolve that action.
A person shall not deliberately select random values for a rules-defined action without intending to use those values to the best of their ability to resolve that action.


If a person has selected some or all of the random values necessary to perform an action, they shall not discard the valid specifications in order to attempt a substantially similar action with the goal of obtaining different random values. If there is consensus that a preponderance of the evidence exists, or if a Judge ruling, not overturned, finds that a player has done such a thing, all attempts other than the first are deemed to be invalid and to not have affected the gamestate.
If a person has selected some or all of the random values necessary to perform an action, they shall not discard the valid specifications in order to attempt a substantially similar action with the goal of obtaining different random values. If there is consensus that a preponderance of the evidence exists, or if a Judge ruling, not overturned, finds that a player has done such a thing, all attempts other than the first are deemed to be invalid and to not have affected the gamestate.


==== Dice Rolls ====
=== Dice Rolls ===
A rule that requires a selection of an NdK value, for non-negative integer N and positive integer K, is requiring the random selection of N rolls of a K-sided die.
A rule that requires a selection of an NdK value, for non-negative integer N and positive integer K, is requiring the random selection of N rolls of a K-sided die.


Line 97: Line 97:
If a rule requires a dice roll with a target number x, this instead produces the number of independent selections that meet or exceed the target number and can be abbreviated as "x+". For example, if a rule requires a dice roll with a target number of 3, this can be abbreviated to "3+".
If a rule requires a dice roll with a target number x, this instead produces the number of independent selections that meet or exceed the target number and can be abbreviated as "x+". For example, if a rule requires a dice roll with a target number of 3, this can be abbreviated to "3+".


== Game Rules ==
= Game Rules =


=== Initialization ===
== Initialization ==
If no spaces exist, then the following occur:
If no spaces exist, then the following occur:
* Spaces are created for each integer N from 0 to 39.
* Spaces are created for each integer N from 0 to 39.
Line 106: Line 106:
* This rule is repealed.
* This rule is repealed.


=== Board ===
== Board ==
Players have a location or current space, which is a space. If a player has no location or if their location is indeterminate, then they move to Space 0, if it exists. If Space 0 does not exist, it is created before this move occurs.
Players have a location or current space, which is a space. If a player has no location or if their location is indeterminate, then they move to Space 0, if it exists. If Space 0 does not exist, it is created before this move occurs.


==== Spaces ====
=== Spaces ===
Spaces are entities. Spaces can be connected to any number of spaces. Connections between spaces are one-directional unless otherwise specified. All spaces that exist in the gamestate constitute the board.
Spaces are entities. Spaces can be connected to any number of spaces. Connections between spaces are one-directional unless otherwise specified. All spaces that exist in the gamestate constitute the board.


Line 118: Line 118:
Spaces are defined by subrules of this rule.
Spaces are defined by subrules of this rule.


===== Blank =====
==== Blank ====
Does nothing when a player stops moving on it, and does nothing when a player moves into it.
Does nothing when a player stops moving on it, and does nothing when a player moves into it.


===== Crystal =====
==== Crystal ====
Any player that moves into this space from a different space gains 1 crystal.
Any player that moves into this space from a different space gains 1 crystal.


=== Movement ===
== Movement ==
Every phase, as an action, each player can roll 1d10 in #game-actions. This is called their "movement roll". Other rules can specify dice to be added to or removed from the set of dice used to make movement rolls.
Every phase, as an action, each player can roll 1d10 in #game-actions. This is called their "movement roll". Other rules can specify dice to be added to or removed from the set of dice used to make movement rolls.


Line 131: Line 131:
* If the player's current space connects to multiple other spaces, they must choose one space their current space connects to, then move to that space.
* If the player's current space connects to multiple other spaces, they must choose one space their current space connects to, then move to that space.


=== Choices ===
== Choices ==
Anytime the rules say a player chooses something, that player must post a valid option to #game-actions by the end of that phase. If a player does not specify all choices that must be made during their action, their action does not occur.
Anytime the rules say a player chooses something, that player must post a valid option to #game-actions by the end of that phase. If a player does not specify all choices that must be made during their action, their action does not occur.


=== Winning ===
== Winning ==
Crystals are fungible, non-transferable items.
Crystals are fungible, non-transferable items.


The first player to own 15 or more crystals and to own at least 5 more crystals than any other player wins.
The first player to own 15 or more crystals and to own at least 5 more crystals than any other player wins.

Revision as of 10:31, 30 November 2023

open questions:

is movement specified correctly?

is the board specified correctly?

Nomic Rules

Time

General

All times mentioned in this ruleset are in UTC. Days start at 00:00 UTC. Weeks start on Monday 00:00 UTC.

Phases

Each week is divided into two phases:

Phase I: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday

Phase II: Friday, Saturday, and Sunday

Rules

A rule is a body of text which governs the state of the game. Rules that are in effect apply continuously. When a player joins the game, they agree to abide by the rules in effect.

A subrule is a rule that claims another rule as its parent. The subrule is not part of the parent; instead this relationship is to be used for organizational purposes.

A rule that is not a subrule is a top-level rule.

Players

Any person may become a player by posting a message setting forth their intent to do so in the channel ⁠#game-actions, provided they have not been a player at any point in the past seven days. A player may cease being a player by sending a message that sets forth their intent to do so in #⁠game-actions.

A player is "reputable" if they have continuously been a player for the previous seven days or if they have continuously been a player from a time that was within 3 days of the round starting.

Proposals

Proposals are made by sending a message in the channel #proposals.

A 👍 or 👎 reaction from a player on a Proposal message at the time when the voting period ends constitutes a vote in favor or against, respectively. If a person's vote is unclear (excluding abstentions), it is considered to be against.

At the end of its voting period, a proposal takes effect if it is popular (as defined for its type) and the message in which it was submitted has been neither deleted nor edited. If more than one proposal would otherwise take effect simultaneously, they take effect in the order in which they were created.

The class of a proposal must be one of the classes listed below. When a proposal is submitted, the submitter may specify its class. if no class is specified, the proposal class defaults to Standard.

Urgent Class Proposal

The voting period of an urgent proposal begins at the time it is submitted and ends two days (48 hours) after. An urgent proposal is popular if it has no more than two votes against it.

Rules to the contrary notwithstanding, only a reputable player can submit an urgent proposal. Urgent proposals should only be used to correct the game to its intended state and to maintain playability.

Standard Class Proposal

The voting period for a standard proposal is the phase that started after the proposal was submitted. A standard proposal is popular if it has more votes in favor than votes against.

Judges

There shall be a sole Judge, responsible for resolving rules disputes. An incumbent Judge can be removed with the assent of two players, but they should not be removed except for abuse of office. A person can cease being the Judge by publicly stating so.

A request for justice shall take the form of a question or statement. The proper response to a question is an answer to that question, and the proper response to a statement is the truth value of that statement.

Upon formal submission of a request for justice by a person other than themself in #request-for-justice, the Judge shall, as quickly as possible, issue a response to the request. This response shall be binding only to the extent that it reasonably directly pertains to the request, and only to the extent that it does not blatantly and obviously contradict rules text while still considering the expressed or clearly implied legislative intent.

Within 4 days of a judge issuing a ruling, a public vote of confidence on that ruling can be initiated in #request-for-justice. Votes may be cast in such a vote for a period of 2 days after initiation. Votes are to be cast by 👍 or 👎 reactions on a clearly designated poll message; if a person's vote is unclear, it is to affirm the judgement. A ruling is overturned if strictly more players vote in favor of overturning than affirming.

A ruling may be overturned by the Judge who made it within one week of being made. When a ruling is overturned in this manner, the Judge shall then issue a new ruling on the initial request, which shall be binding in the same manner as the original ruling.

An overturned ruling shall have no bearing on the interpretation of the rules or of the gamestate.

Any reputable player may become a candidate for the Judge by sending a message in the channel #judge-elections. If there are any Judge candidacies put forward during a week, the player whose message is both popular and has the most 👍 reactions from players becomes the Judge once that week ends. A Judge Candidacy message is popular if it has more 👍 than 👎 reactions from players on its initiating message. Ties are broken in favor of the player with the earliest text message during that week.

Items

Items are entities defined as such by the rules. Items can be owned by players. When an item's owner cannot reasonably be determined using publicly available information, or if it would be owned by a non-player, it is instead destroyed.

For an entity to gain an item is for that item to be created in that entity's possession. To grant an entity an item is to create it in that entity's possession.

For an entity to lose an item is for that item to be destroyed from that entity's possession. To revoke an item from an entity is to destroy it from that entity's possession.

Reputable players can trade items with other reputable players.

Trading

A trade is an exchange or transfer of items between two entities, with each entity giving a specified finite set of items to the other.

When otherwise authorized, a trade between two players takes place when both players explicitly consent to the trade in #trades within 7 days of each other.

Actions

When defining a game action that can be performed by sending a message, the rules should specify a channel where the game action can be taken. If the rules enable performing an action by sending a message without providing for a specific channel, the action can be taken by sending a message in #game-actions. Similarly, if the rules provide that a game action can be taken without making any provision for any method to take that action, the action can be taken by sending a message in #game-actions.

Actions that are to be performed by sending a message are done by sending a message in the appropriate channel that clearly and unambiguously sets forth intent for the action to be taken.

Whenever a player performs an action that would modify the information that the players generally agree should be tracked, that player should make a reasonable effort to track the outcome of the action in the generally-agreed-upon applicable location.

Random Choices

A person shall not deliberately select random values for a rules-defined action without intending to use those values to the best of their ability to resolve that action.

If a person has selected some or all of the random values necessary to perform an action, they shall not discard the valid specifications in order to attempt a substantially similar action with the goal of obtaining different random values. If there is consensus that a preponderance of the evidence exists, or if a Judge ruling, not overturned, finds that a player has done such a thing, all attempts other than the first are deemed to be invalid and to not have affected the gamestate.

Dice Rolls

A rule that requires a selection of an NdK value, for non-negative integer N and positive integer K, is requiring the random selection of N rolls of a K-sided die.

If not otherwise specified, this produces the sum of N rolls of a K-sided die; that is, the sum of N independent selections of integers from 1 to K, using a uniform random distribution. If N is zero, the sum is zero.

If a rule requires a dice roll with a target number x, this instead produces the number of independent selections that meet or exceed the target number and can be abbreviated as "x+". For example, if a rule requires a dice roll with a target number of 3, this can be abbreviated to "3+".

Game Rules

Initialization

If no spaces exist, then the following occur:

  • Spaces are created for each integer N from 0 to 39.
  • Each space N is connected to space N+1, except for space 39, which is connected to space 0.
  • The type of space 0 is set to Crystal.
  • This rule is repealed.

Board

Players have a location or current space, which is a space. If a player has no location or if their location is indeterminate, then they move to Space 0, if it exists. If Space 0 does not exist, it is created before this move occurs.

Spaces

Spaces are entities. Spaces can be connected to any number of spaces. Connections between spaces are one-directional unless otherwise specified. All spaces that exist in the gamestate constitute the board.

Each space has an identifier, which is an integer. A space with identifier N can be called "Space N".

Each space has a type, which is, by default, Blank.

Spaces are defined by subrules of this rule.

Blank

Does nothing when a player stops moving on it, and does nothing when a player moves into it.

Crystal

Any player that moves into this space from a different space gains 1 crystal.

Movement

Every phase, as an action, each player can roll 1d10 in #game-actions. This is called their "movement roll". Other rules can specify dice to be added to or removed from the set of dice used to make movement rolls.

Immediately after a player makes their movement roll, while that player has not moved a number of spaces equal to their movement roll, the following occur:

  • If the player's current space only connects to one other space, then the player automatically moves to that space.
  • If the player's current space connects to multiple other spaces, they must choose one space their current space connects to, then move to that space.

Choices

Anytime the rules say a player chooses something, that player must post a valid option to #game-actions by the end of that phase. If a player does not specify all choices that must be made during their action, their action does not occur.

Winning

Crystals are fungible, non-transferable items.

The first player to own 15 or more crystals and to own at least 5 more crystals than any other player wins.